some guy from the esp forum uploaded this
it was played live in berlin

sounds crap imo, its just st anger II

mp3:
http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.p...57D8D737F7DC0BA

video on youtube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fb699wy-cnQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ADP_eDAuhg

Bah, dosn`t sound good at all. Normaly, I wouldn`t say anything based on such shitty sound quality, but come on, this is Metallica.

__________________

crap=Metallica=crap

__________________

Here we go.............

.............It's shit, I hate it, Well I hate Metallica11111, It's better than St Anger, I really like Load, Load is shit MOP is best and you're a fag, Kirk Hammet's a shit guitarist, Don't call me a fag you Opeth bum boy, Yeah Kirk is shit Dave Mustaine wrote the best riffs, I can't wait to see them at Download they'll be killer, IMO the song is boring metallcrappa are past it, I'm not an Opeth bum boy you Hetfield arse licker, It's a fucking terrible song, Metallica were best before they released Kill 'em All, James is crap now he's sober, I've never liked Metallica, Megadeth all the way, I'm not a James Hetfield arse licker you cloudy cunt discharge(Robbie Filth will be tabbing that song next week ), I've no interest in this but I'll post anyway, They'll be shite at Download as Slipknot will blow them away!, Aweful song but then I expected it to be they've never been any good since Cliff died, My dads will hit your dad cuz he's bigger than you, AJFA is the best album, yeah your dad hasn't got ten mates you dangly sperm sack, *insert MOD comment which generally calls everyone retards and then the thread gets locked*

There, I've summerised the next 30 odd posts in this thread to save you all the hassle of having to post and get upset as it turns in to the usual Metallica slag fest!
Now a mod please lock this

__________________

Crap I guess... James' voice sound more and more like a country singer.

Whatever, I still really respect Metallica.

__________________

I can't be sure, because the sound quality of the video was so bad, but the second half of that song seems like it might actually rock

I can't get the MP3 to work. Is it just a sound recording of the video or a different version?

__________________

Crap. Crap. Crap.

__________________

I agree. I can't make a very good judgement call on this. From the sound of it, it sounds super weak though.

__________________

nobrain=obrien20=nobrain

@topic sounds pretty much like st anger

__________________

Metallica is crap........now

Well I guess Tranny doesn't need to post in here

Veeerrry funny Mr. Englishman

__________________

An old friend of mine introduced me to Metallica, starting my way into metal in general way before I knew what whas happening. But, then I was suddenly confronted with what had happened during the 90's.

Can anyone, without regressing to the usual childischness explain why they suddenly shifted, more or less, onto the same road as the power ballad-toting high-hairs of the eighties?

__________________

It doesn't sound as bad as I expected, honestly.

I think I'll check out what I can from the new album whenever I have the option, but I'll be god damned if I'm going to pay a dime to hear it.

__________________

Hahaha, silly Metallica.

__________________

a-fucking-men!

Money mate, the filthy green stuff!
They were frightened of being forgotten as the thrash movement started to die, thus they changed style to that of more lucrative trad rock act, worked with a big hair rock producer, made videos to get MTV airplay, started wearing make up and feather boas and basically became everything they said they wouldn't become. Then when heavy music and thrash started to make a resurgence a few years ago they decide it's cool to be agro again and released St Anger to much mirth and ridicule from the record buying public!

__________________

fuck metallica...fucking sellouts

__________________

Hey, eat my shit you ignorant music tasteless.

__________________

im no Metallica expert, but how simplistic was that drumming? Blink 182 or yellow card have better drumming

nah trust me, its because of the bit rate of the video. When you hear it live you hear all the blast beats and arpeggios and shit.

TRUST.

__________________

crap song. At least it has a solo this time, even though it's boring.

__________________

I like the guy at the start when james talks and everyone shouts "YEAH!!!!" except one guy who sounds really bored and goes "yeah."

And regarding the song it's better than anything off st anger but its still pretty fuck arse.

__________________

Reading through this thread it looks like my comments made in post 4 are coming to fruit

__________________

St. Anger? I thought you died last time??

To top it off, you can hear how old the audience is. (James) "You still out there?" (Audience) "errrrrehhhh uhhhhh" (Audience) "Wow....larz played so double bass....oooohhhh"......"and they just played the same riff 5,478 times!!!"

__________________

Thats more like how the audience acts at a Slipknot show.

__________________

youre ability to analyse the comments of others and classify them wether they support your opinion or not lacks at least as much as youre sense to express yourself precisely without sounding unschooled or mentally handicaped.

@philkilla although the new album will suck pretty much like st anger i still like their preformance live ... at least when they skip the new songs. this actually sounds sad ... anyways ... i saw em at rock am ring and i liked it.

__________________

English is not Marino's native language - I bet he speaks (and writes) better English than you do Portuguese.

__________________

all those blastbeats are ghostnotes actually,they are there only to accentuate the most primordial solid,in the pocket,groove, hard rock drumbeat known to man. no cowbells left alive


threads on metallica are like a turkey shoot

Yeah the second part of it sounded not too bad. At least they do solo's again. But they have a long road to go to wash away those years of shame. I stopped giving them credit a very long time ago, so i am not going to waste more time on them now.

Your lucky,i had to be introduced by S.O.A.D.
BLASPHEMY!!!!!!!!!!!

__________________

hahaha you won your bet i dont speak any portuguese plus english is not my naitive language either dude ... anyways i was not referring to bad english i was referring to "eat my shit".

__________________

blink 182 has better drumming than most metal bands.

__________________

James sounds like a little whiney bitch....

__________________

james _is_ a whiney bitch. never watched "some kind of monster" ? I suggest you do.

__________________

Not at all, dude.

__________________

Meh,better than st anger.

Agreed.
The old, old stuff was a fucking joke though, even for 1983. Slayer were even decent back then!

Folk say the 'Tallica are completely above all us undergrounders. No, they're not. They're just another band. And one that died a long time ago.

__________________

elephant cuntish is marino's native language. He was still a young boy when he was eating the elephant twat....poor poor little guy.

__________________

Actualy I did see it,
And I enjoyed it aswell but I still think he is a little sissy, but who cares he has his problems I have mine.. But I seen the show on a downloadsite so maybe tonight I will check it out hopefully the quallity is good.

__________________

The second half sounded better than all their more recent efforts comebined.

HAHAHA!

__________________

Metallica suck. Period. I like Kill 'Em All and some of Ride The Lightning, but anything else I hate. Yes including Master Of Puppets.

__________________

Blink drummer rules.

That was lame. boooooooooooooooooooo....get off the stage you bums!

__________________

I fucking agree with you there. That is the only shit I listen to. Master of Puppets song went on and on and on it was like...shut the fuck up you lost my attention already with your shite acoustic interlude and 15 choruses.

Metallica's apex was Kill 'em All and it went down hill from there...they should take their own advice and "hit the lights"...lame yeah...

What they NEED to do to be seen as a thrash act again is fucking speed up and make some good riffs. I had hope for the beginning of that song...I was thinking that it might be something like Vio-lence - Eternal Nightmare where it starts off slow and then goes into brutal fast thrash...no i don't even know why I got my hopes up.

__________________

METALLICA RULES!!!!










*sarcasm*

__________________

Metallica should REALLY quit now.

__________________

God I miss old school Metallica

__________________

Their last album sucks,none the less,they are still one of the greatest metal bands.

LOL You know what I just realized Metallica was only good with Dave Mustaine. I mean Metallica stole Dave's songs for Kill 'Em All and Ride The Lightning so it makes me wonder. But actually Metallica would have sucked even if they kept Dave in the band because I mean look at Megadeth now "System Has Failed". (SHUDDERS) UUUUHHHHGGG

__________________

they both suck now...I think mustaine wouldn't have been allowed to make bad ass shit if he stayed in metallica. I'm sure the fucking goblin Larz would try to stop him...

__________________

Shut your filthy fucking post about Dave. You know Metallica wound still be a better band with Dave.

__________________

bullshit

__________________

True, after all he did write some of the classics.

__________________

No, he had input on some of the classics, which is very different to writing the classics.

__________________

yah, take out James and put in Dave...haha

__________________

yeah and while your at it, take out kirk, lars and robert aswell

__________________

I say they just make Metallica's new lineup Lars Ulrich, James Hetfield, the "other guy" from Wham!, and Gloria Estefan.

I think I would actually buy that album, and that has nothing to do with my closet love of the band Wham!

Since this has basically turned into another "I hate metallica" jackoff session, I figure I'll throw in a ridiculous post or two before this thread gets shitcanned.

__________________

Nothing posted on the internet about Metallica will never be complete without arguments over Mustaine.

Shit guys, this thread was about the crappy new song and somehow it still revolves around Metallica VS Megadeth. You are a bunch of whiney emo kids not getting over the fact their abusive parents got divorced.

__________________

Well there you you go I must be fucking psychic way back in post 4 I out lined all the comments that would follow to save you all the hassle of having to write anything in this thread but would you listen? No!

You ignore the lessons of history at your own peril!

http://metaltabs.com/forum/showthre...light=Metallica

http://metaltabs.com/forum/showthre...light=Metallica

Gawd some of you could have been out getting laid or something!

__________________

hahahaha

__________________

Well that probably wouldn't have happened for approx. 99% of the people here

__________________

God it's the easiest thing in the world to bash Metallica. They're just easy targets now. You'd think people would move on. Christ.

ANYWHO I kinda dig the new song. I went "holy shit" when I heard the double bass, the signature Kirk solo(by signature I mean pentatonic wah crazy unintelligable shredding that has nothing on Dime, Zakk, Randy, Eddie or any other guitar masters but I've accepted anyway), and the thrash picking after the solo. I never had a problem with St. Anger's guitar riffs so that view went on to this song. And I liked it that they went to pack a million riffs into one song like they did with Justice.

James's voice was weak. I wish he would fucking see Melissa Cross or something and learn how to sing again.

So I thought it was pretty good. No it won't touch Puppet's but I think it rocks pretty hard.

Funny dream I had. I dreamt I saw Metallica last night in some packed arena. But when they went into their fourth song, EVERYBODY cleared the arena at ONCE. Except me I stayed and tried to pimp my band out to them by showing them my myspace but that was a failure and I woke up before I got their opinions of our tunes.

__________________

i have herd the new song by Metallica and i think the song is allright. it's nothing like "Master of Puppets" or " For Whom The Bell Tolls". Metallica should have stoped making music after Cliff died. after Cliff died metallica lost thier spark as musicians. although i have great respect for metallica, i feel that there time of glory was done after "Puppets".

__________________

And Justice slays!

__________________

Arpeggios? It sounds like the same riff over and over again then chorus, then same riff, solo, same riff...wait...i almost thought that it wasnt metallica for a second. Yeah it sounds like metallica..

__________________

...And Justice For All was pretty good, some really cool riffs and stuff. i don't like the drums on the album. maybe it's just because Lars Ulrich blows balls when it comes to drumming

__________________

hasnt he been the drummer for like 20 odd years?

__________________

yeah something like that, but i still think he sucks. i mean if Neil Peart from Rush and Lars Ulrich were to have a drum battle, Niel Peart would blow Lars right out of the water.

__________________

neil pert would blow anybody out of the water,
not just lars

__________________

well said

__________________

No point in that comparison. Very few bands should have a Neil Peart, good as he is.

have any of you herd that excuse of an album that Metallica put out called
"S&M" ( san fransisco symphony and metallica)? that shit sucked! i bought it and as soon as i herd the first song, i ran as fast as i could back " Music World" and got my money back, and i bought some new strings for my bass.

__________________