Isahn V.S Akerfeldt

[JAMF]

Both are highly talented at both screaming and normal singing styles, but who is the better of the two?

[Transient]

this is the best VS thread ive ever seen actually

wow

id go with akerfeldt

[MoonRaven]

wrong forum, methinks, but akerfeldt FTW

[Dyvim Tvar]

Jeeeez, that's one hard question (for me at least)! I just can't choose, i'll have to give this one some long thought!

[timedragon]

Isahn today. Akerfeldt a quite some time ago, so im going with current Isahn.

[HELLBLASTER-666]

before it gets closed Ihsahn,though I don't like either one much

[problematic]

yeah this is quite pointless.

[brainsforbreakfast]

Akerfeld on both growling and cleans!

[DeathCS]

Akerfeldt.

[Blood Red Bass]

Screaming comes down to a preference of black metal shrieks to death metal growls, but I think Adkerfelt is clearly the better singer.

[newHELLonEARTH]

I'm going to say Isahn because I liked him alot on Prometheus, and because I fucking hate Opeth

[DeathCS]

I'm going to say Isahn because I liked him alot on Prometheus, and because I fucking hate Opeth
Well, You're gay.

[MetalThrashingMad]

I'm going to say Isahn because I liked him alot on Prometheus, and because I fucking hate Opeth
Hah yeah, sometimes I like Isahn, but I always just find Akerfeldt annoying. It's a smoke show in my opinion, Isahn by a long shot.

[moe_blunts]

Screaming comes down to a preference of black metal shrieks to death metal growls, but I think Adkerfelt is clearly the better singer.

...ishan took opera and his singin voice is quite epic. "thus spake the nightspirit" anyone?? or how about "inno a satana"?


thing is, i've gotten over my fad with both bands, so it is hard for me to say. i said akerfeldt purely for the transitions from distortion to clean

[YOUR_GOD_IS_DEAD]

Akerfeldt

[Requiem]

Akerfeldt lol you should of known my answer.

[brainsforbreakfast]

well, I chose Akerfeld on merits of his voice, not technique.

[Cloaca]

Ihsahn belts the living shite out of Akerfeldt. His voice is much more unique in my opinion, not to mention his song arrangements are way better.

[Sycophant]

Emperor > Opeth

Don't even get me started.

[problematic]

Well, this thread isn't exactly about what band you prefer, but who's a better vocalist.

So in that respect, I chose Akerfeldt. His got a great emotional singing voice, and I wish I could growl like him.

Isahn is good and unique too, But Akerfeldt is more versatile. Isahn can get boring. Meh.

[Robbie Filth]

Akerfeldt definately.

[metal_monkey]

Akerfeldt

[The Execrator]

Isahn has the best fucking scream in metal.

[timedragon]

yeah this is quite pointless.
less than 24 hours later...
Well, this thread isn't exactly about what band you prefer, but who's a better vocalist.

So in that respect, I chose Akerfeldt. His got a great emotional singing voice, and I wish I could growl like him.

Isahn is good and unique too, But Akerfeldt is more versatile. Isahn can get boring. Meh.
:rolleyes:

[Bones98]

ISAHN!!